What Makes Church Members Click Away from Online Ads: Key Issues to Fix

Jono Long • May 25, 2025

Online ads can be a great way for churches to connect with their communities. From promoting events to inviting new visitors, a well-placed ad has the potential to lead someone to take their next step toward church. But what happens when those ads get ignored, skipped, or simply fail to inspire any clicks at all? That’s where things get frustrating. You've taken the time to write the message, create the graphic, and schedule it, only to get little to no response. It's more common than you think, and the reasons often come down to predictably fixable problems.


When ads don’t perform well, the issue usually isn’t the platform or the people. It’s how the ad was shaped. A few small missteps in the setup can lead church members—or potential visitors—to scroll right past. As a company that specializes in advertising for churches, Faithworks Marketing sees this happen often. The good news is there are ways to improve it, and it starts by taking a step back and asking if the ad truly reaches the right person, in the right way, at the right time.


Misunderstood Audience


One of the biggest reasons church ads get skipped is because they don’t actually speak to the person looking at them. If the message is too general or doesn't line up with what the viewer cares about, it tends to get ignored. It's not that the ad is bad—it just isn't connecting with the person it was hoping to reach.


Churches often try to please everyone with one message, and that ends up working for no one. A post meant to reach young families might not work if it reads like it’s directed at retirees. A single mom scrolling through social media after dinner is going to connect better with an ad that shows another busy parent finding peace during a service, not a generic invitation to join us tomorrow at 10.


Here’s how to better connect with your audience:


1. Focus each ad on one group. If you're targeting parents, use real family life moments in your message and photos. If you want to speak to college students, make sure the language isn’t too formal and the visuals feel current.


2. Think about daily schedules. Parents might scroll after putting the kids to bed. Older adults may check emails earlier in the morning. Time your ads to match this rhythm.


3. Pay attention to tone. Does your message sound inviting or like a bulletin announcement? People tend to respond more when the tone feels warm, conversational, and real.


Getting a strong response starts with knowing who you're talking to. Once that’s clear, your message can be crafted to speak directly to them—and that’s where real engagement begins.


Weak Calls To Action


The message might be perfect, the design might look great, and the timing might be right—but if people don’t know what to do next, your ad falls flat. This happens all the time with church ads. They share the what (like an event) or the when (the time and place), but they forget to add the how. That simple next step is called the call to action, and it’s one of the most powerful tools in your ad.


A weak or missing call to action leaves the viewer unsure about what’s supposed to happen next. Are they supposed to register? Click a link? Just show up? Without clarity, they might just move on. People need to be gently guided, and your ad should make the next steps clear.


Here are a few things to avoid:


- Vague phrases like Learn more with no context

- No link or direction at all

- Pushing too many options in one place, which causes confusion


Instead, you want to keep your call to action clean, direct, and easy to follow. Try:


- RSVP here with a clear link or button

- Click to sign up and save a spot

- Watch the video now


Don’t stuff too much into the ad either. Stick with one focused step. If the goal is to get someone to register for a volunteer info session, don’t also try to promote a future potluck or small group kickoff at the same time. Keep it simple and let the action match the message.


Your audience shouldn’t have to guess what to do. Make it as easy as possible, and the chances they’ll follow through go way up. Small wording changes here can lead to way better results.


Poor Visual Appeal


When someone sees your ad, their first reaction is based on what it looks like. If the visuals don’t catch their eye right away, they’re gone. People scroll fast, and design often plays a bigger role than words in stopping that scroll. If the image or layout is busy, hard to read, or just plain boring, your message probably won’t even get a glance.


One common issue is when ads are too crowded. A flyer-style graphic stuffed into a digital space doesn’t usually work well. It’s a different kind of platform, and simple always does better. Another mistake is using low-quality or stretched images. They can make your church look less welcoming or less professional without you even realizing it.


Here are a few ways to improve your ad visuals:


1. Use high-quality, clear images that feel real. Avoid stock photos that look too staged or impersonal.

2. Make text easy to read with clear font choices and high contrast.

3. Keep the layout clean. Use space wisely and don’t cram everything into one graphic.

4. Make sure your color scheme fits your church’s tone without being too loud or too dull.

5. Always test how your ad looks on phones since that’s where most people will see it.


A simple example: An ad for a Sunday picnic might do better with a single bright photo of smiling church members outdoors under a tent, paired with one short line of text and a clear button to RSVP. That’s it. No address block, no tiny logos, no clutter. When design invites instead of overwhelms, people usually respond much better.


Bad Timing And Placement


Even the best ad won't do much if it's running when no one is looking or showing up in the wrong places. Timing and placement have a huge impact on whether your message gets seen or just floats by unnoticed. It's easy to assume more time running an ad means more views, but it doesn’t always work that way.


One problem is promoting something too early. For example, if you invite people to a church camp three months ahead, there's a chance they’ll forget about it by the time the date rolls around. On the other hand, posting it just a day or two before might not give viewers enough time to make plans.


You also need to think about where the ad shows up. An Instagram ad might work great for younger adults but be less effective with older members who check emails more often. Running the same exact ad across all platforms without adjusting it can lead to wasted efforts.


To get the most from your investment, pay close attention to:


1. When your audience is online. Run ads during peak scroll times like early mornings, lunch breaks, or evenings.


2. Seasonal timing. Don’t advertise outdoor gatherings during bad weather months or indoor events at a time when people want to be outside.


3. Matching the platform to the audience. Post images and reels on Instagram for younger groups, while using email or Facebook for a more mixed or older community.


Ads should meet people where they already are and at the moment they’re most likely to care. Get those two things right, and your reach will go a lot further.


Bringing It All Together


Getting people to click on church ads doesn’t have to feel like guessing in the dark. Most of the time, if something isn't working, it's because the ad missed the mark in a few simple ways. Either it wasn't speaking clearly to a specific audience, it lacked a next step, the image was off, or it showed up at the wrong time. The good news is that all of these things are fixable without having to completely rethink your church messaging.


Online ads work best when they feel like a natural fit in someone’s life. When they see something real, helpful, and easy to engage with, clicking becomes more natural. Whether you're weighing the right photo to use or picking when to run your next post, small thoughtful changes can make a big difference.


The key is to stay focused on who you're trying to reach and why. If your message is sincere, your design approach is clean, and your timing is smart, you’ll start to see more of that scroll-stopping attention and real engagement. And when you’re ready to take the next step and strengthen your church ads, Faithworks Marketing is here to help.


Ready to transform the effectiveness of your church's online outreach efforts? Discover how strategic
advertising for churches can connect you more deeply with your community. By refining your ad strategies, your church will experience better engagement and interaction. At Faithworks Marketing, we're here to help you every step of the way with insights and expertise tailored to your needs. Get in touch to find out how we can assist in amplifying your message and grow your church community.

Jono Long

Digital Marketer for 10 years. Formerly a Youth Pastor for 21 years.

A man with a beard is sitting in a chair wearing a hat.

Latest Posts

church ad campaign
By Jono Long June 1, 2025
Discover strategies for successful church advertising. Learn how to connect with your community through effective advertising for churches.
church ad
By Jono Long May 18, 2025
Struggling with church advertising campaigns? Discover solutions to improve your results and engage effectively with advertising for churches.
By Jono Long May 8, 2025
Discover how the Google Ad Grant boosts church outreach. Let Faithworks Marketing help you connect with more people and strengthen your community.
Church Online Ads
By Jono Long May 6, 2025
Discover how effective online ads for churches can boost event participation and community interaction. Let Faithworks Marketing guide your strategy.
By Jono Long May 1, 2025
“Jesus is for everyone. Your church is not.” That one sentence from Tyler Hardin of Firm Foundations Marketing perfectly sums up a major challenge most churches face today: a lack of clarity. In a recent episode of the Pro Church Marketing Podcast, host Jono Long sat down with Tyler to unpack why churches struggle with growth—even when they’re doing “all the right things.” Whether it's pouring money into Facebook ads or launching a shiny new website, many churches find themselves exhausted, frustrated, and stuck. The reason? They’re starting in the wrong place. The Real Reason Your Church Isn’t Growing Churches often begin with tactics: running ads, creating flyers, redesigning websites. But as Tyler points out, none of those efforts work if you don’t first understand who you’re trying to reach. Too many churches aim for generic goals like “young families” or “unchurched people” without any meaningful definition behind those labels. “If you say you want to reach young families,” Tyler says, “is that a couple in their 30s with toddlers or a single mom in her 40s with teens? Those lives are completely different.” Knowing your community isn’t a marketing luxury—it’s a ministry necessity. Why “We Want to Reach Everyone” Doesn’t Work Most pastors are quick to say, “We just want to reach our community. Everyone is welcome!” While the heart behind that is beautiful, the strategy behind it falls flat. “When you say you're trying to reach everyone, you reach no one,” Tyler explains. “Your message becomes generic. Your ministries don’t feel relevant. And your people are overextended trying to do everything.” Defining a target audience isn’t about excluding people—it’s about making sure someone feels truly seen, known, and served. The 5 Ps: A Simple Framework for Clarity Not sure where to begin? Tyler offers a free, powerful tool: the 5 Ps of Church Target Audience . People – Who are they? (Age, family status, lifestyle) Place – Where are they coming from? (Zip codes, neighborhoods, travel time) Passions – What lights them up? (Causes, community involvement, values) Pain Points – What are they struggling with? (Loneliness, addiction, parenting stress) Pursuits – What are they chasing? (Career, belonging, stability) Start with these. Talk to your members. Ask your community leaders. You don’t need a big budget—just a notebook, a few conversations, and a curious heart. Authenticity Over Hype Many churches feel tempted to “pretty up” their marketing—using photos of young families they don’t actually have, or hyping ministries that are barely off the ground. Tyler’s advice? Don’t. “Embrace who you are. There are people who want your small church, your traditional service, your real community,” he says. Instead of trying to be what you're not, show people what you are. If your sanctuary is full of seniors who love hymns, let that shine. If your church loves messy people and recovery ministry, make that your message. Authenticity is magnetic. Healthy Growth Means Intentional Growth We all want to grow. But fast growth without systems leads to burnout and disconnection. Healthy growth, Tyler explains, is marked by: Clear next steps for guests Real relationships, not just high attendance Sustainable ministry paced for your capacity Growth isn’t just about numbers—it’s about souls. It’s about caring for the people who do show up and making sure they’re known, discipled, and connected. What If You’re a Small, Rural, or Declining Church? Don’t count yourself out. Tyler shared a story of a 30-member church in rural Pennsylvania—mostly seniors—who discovered through research that they were ideally positioned to serve a specific group in their area. They didn’t need to become a megachurch. They just needed to become more intentional. If you can’t afford professional research yet, start with conversations. Ask local teachers, council members, or even families at the grocery store: What’s our community struggling with? What are people looking for in a church? The answers might surprise you—and guide your next steps. Take the First Step Today Clarity doesn’t come from copying the latest trends. It comes from asking better questions. Start with the 5 Ps. Talk to your people. And if you're ready for a deeper dive, check out the community research services at Firm Foundations Marketing . Your church doesn’t need to become something it’s not. It just needs to become more of what it already is—on purpose, with clarity, and with love for the people God has called you to reach.
church digital marketing solutions
By Jono Long April 28, 2025
Elevate your church's reach with Faithworks Marketing. Discover strategies for visibility and engaging wider audiences using digital tools.
Google Ad
By Jono Long April 21, 2025
Discover how the Google Ad Grant can boost church outreach, enhance visibility, and engage your community effectively. Learn strategies for success today.
church
By Jono Long April 13, 2025
Discover effective strategies for church social media management to strengthen your community's online engagement and reach your target audience.
By Jono Long April 9, 2025
It’s the same story in churches across the country. You ask pastors, “What’s your biggest struggle?” And more often than not, the answer is the same: leadership development . From small churches to megachurches, pastors are feeling the pressure — “I just don’t have enough leaders.” The strange part? We live in the most content-rich leadership culture in history. Search “church leadership” on Amazon or YouTube, and you’ll be buried in books, sermons, and training videos. So what’s the disconnect? According to leadership expert and Multiply Group founder Mac Lake, we don’t have a content problem—we have a process problem . In a recent conversation on the Pro Church Marketing Podcast, Mac dropped some serious wisdom that every pastor and ministry leader needs to hear. If your church is stuck, frustrated, or flat-out burned out from trying to raise up leaders, read on. We Don’t Have a Content Problem—We Have a Process Problem Mac has been in the trenches—planting churches, coaching pastors, and working alongside ministries of all sizes. One of the most shocking stats he shared? A survey conducted in both 2008 and 2018 showed the exact same thing: leadership development was still the #1 issue churches faced. In other words, 10 years passed and nothing changed . Why? Because churches have misunderstood what leadership development actually is. “In America, we think, ‘If I said it, you got it.’ We think dumping information equals transformation.” — Mac Lake But real leadership development isn’t about downloading content into people’s heads. It’s about walking with them through a process that transforms their character, skillset, and capacity. Common Mistakes Churches Make in Leadership Development Here’s the hard truth: most churches are doing leadership placement, not leadership development. Instead of building from the ground up, we’re hoping to recruit already-polished volunteers from other churches. Instead of developing a healthy leadership culture, we throw new volunteers into ministry after two weeks of shadowing and hope for the best. Mac calls this “putting someone in the batting cage, throwing two pitches, and then sending them into a ballgame.” The result? Frustrated leaders. Bottlenecks. Burnout. Another mistake: confusing readiness with willingness . “We're looking for readiness, not willingness. And there’s a shortage in our pipelines because we never built a culture of leadership development yesterday.” — Mac Lake If we wait for perfect, fully-formed leaders to appear, we’ll be waiting forever. Instead, we need to spot potential, not polish. What Jesus Modeled—and Why We’re Missing It Let’s take a cue from the ultimate leadership developer: Jesus. Mac broke down Jesus’ leadership process chronologically. For nearly 21 months , Jesus hung out with future disciples before appointing the 12. Once He did, He didn’t just dump knowledge on them. He apprenticed them intentionally —giving them both content and real-life ministry experience. “He spent a disproportionate amount of time with a few to impact the many.” — Mac Lake And here’s the key: the 12 weren’t perfect. They still argued about who was the greatest. But Jesus saw potential. He saw what they could become—not just where they were. In contrast, many modern churches are intimidated by church culture. We bend our methods to keep people happy, rather than following biblical principles. But Mac puts it plainly: “Do you want to build your church around cultural norms or biblical principles?” Building a Scalable Leadership Pipeline So what’s the alternative? How do we actually build leaders? It starts with a pipeline—a clearly defined structure that identifies where someone is, and what they need to grow to the next level. Mac outlines five key stages in the leadership pipeline: Lead Self – personal responsibility, spiritual maturity. Lead Others – small groups, teams, entry-level leadership. Lead Leaders – coaching, oversight of team leaders. Lead a Ministry/Department – directors, strategic leaders. Lead the Church – pastors, executive staff. At each level, there should be clear competencies, character traits , and onboarding systems . This framework not only helps identify current leaders, but allows churches to measure the “depth chart” in every ministry area—just like a football team knows its backups. Where to Start—Even If You’re Busy and Bi-Vocational Here’s the encouraging part: this doesn’t require massive teams, software, or budgets. “All it takes is picking two people and walking them through a process.” — Mac Lake Mac recommends starting with two current leaders who you trust. Walk them through his book Leading Others, a leadership development tool built for churches. Meet every other week. Talk through the competencies. Let them try. Then, challenge them to do the same with two new people the next semester. This developer-to-developer model mirrors Jesus’ ministry and multiplies impact faster than hiring more staff. Real-Life Example: From Small Group to Movement Mac shared a story about his wife—a stay-at-home grandma—who started a women’s small group. After one semester, she picked three women to meet with every other week using Leading Others. By the next semester, those women launched their own groups. And she started the process again. Now those three women are training their own future leaders. Just like that, 12 new small group leaders are born—not by accident, but through intentional development. And that’s the secret sauce: simple, reproducible systems that start with relationship. Final Thoughts: Stop Looking—Start Building If your church is struggling to find leaders, don’t be discouraged. The problem isn’t your people. It’s not even your budget. The problem is that we haven’t been discipling people to lead like Jesus. It’s time to make a shift. ✅ Stop looking for pre-packaged leaders. ✅ Start developing the willing. ✅ Move from “doers” to “developers.” ✅ And build a leadership culture that lasts. Whether you’re a full-time pastor or bi-vocational leader, the path forward is clear: start small, start now, and stay consistent . 🔗 Resources Mentioned: Get the Free eBook: Rethinking Leadership Development Mac Lake on Instagram Learn more at MultiplyGroup.org
church service
By Jono Long April 8, 2025
Discover the benefits of digital marketing for churches. Enhance outreach, engagement, and visibility with strategies tailored for your church community.
More Posts